Guest Stars Jared Padalecki as Himself Lindsey Morgan as Herself Sonequa Martin-Green as Herself Lennie James as Himself Gina Torres as Herself Alan Tudyk as Himself Eliza Taylor as Herself (Eliza Taylor-Cotter) Bob Morley as Himself Patrick Stewart as Himself Courtney Ford as Herself Caity Lotz as Herself Leah Lewis as Herself Sam Heughan as Himself Genevieve Padalecki as Herself (Genevieve Cortese) Maddison Jaizani as Herself Kennedy McMann as Herself Tiffany Haddish as Herself Ralph Macchio as Himself William Zabka as Himself Martin Kove as Himself