Guest Stars Inbar Lavi as Eve Scott Porter as Carol Corbett Matt Corboy as Officer Diggs Chris Coy as Alan Bjørn Johnson as Magnar Elizabeth Grullon as Erika Deyo Forteza as Keaton Call Co Starring Adam Wylie as Short Magician Rob Zabrecky as Horace Goldfinger Maggie Carney as Theater Manager Eddie Blackwell as Belios