Guest Stars Autry Haydon-Wilson as Janus Forsythe Silas Weir Mitchell as Boyd Suttree Denis Shepherd as Teenage Yates Forsythe Matt Battaglia as Younger Judge Forsythe Brett Rice as Uncle BB Elaine Hendrix voices Devoe Shifflet Austin Freeman as Teenage Boyd Suttree Charmin Lee as Poochie LaVerne Co Starring Jackson Tessmer as Reynolds Forsythe Heather Gilliland as Marci Strong Paul Danner as Teenage Dickie Barrett Lauren L. Murray as Younger Byrd Forsythe Sherri Eakin as Lenore Suttree Samantha Beaulieu as Prosecutor Jonathan Bergman as Young Yates Forsythe Christine Fuchs as Judge Wilson Jason Edwards as Officer Duquesne Damon Lipari as Nelson Sampson Jessica Elizabeth Johnson as Crista Shawn Sanz as Prison Guard Mustafa Harris as Coach Bradley Rhonda Dents as Nurse Opal Julia Badinger as Young Janus Forsythe Jeremy T. Thomas as Young Boyd Suttree James Evermore as Cocaine Bob Cindy Copeland as Younger Mrs. Timpkins Casey Ferrand as Gloria Steven Walker as Jay Hunter Uncredited Emily Peachey as Liza Sampson