Guest Stars Jason Ritter as Eric Romy Rosemont as Shelly Ricky He as Don B.J. Britt as Isaac Martin Jerry Ferrara as Todd Pilzner Marcia Gay Harden as Alice Mendez Sutton Foster as Chloe Myers Co Starring Kalvin Olafson as Bryan Craig Haas as Josh Bronwen Smith as Saleswoman Robert Corness as Owner Hector Johnson as Judge Madeleine Kelders as EMT #1 Destiny Millns as Avery Troy Mundle as Bailiff Blythe Hubbard as Taylor Jessie Liang as Nurse