Special Guest Stars Marcia Gay Harden as Maggie Brener Mindy Kaling as Audra David Morse as Mr. Jackson Guest Stars Tom Irwin as Fred Micklen Janina Gavankar as Alison Namazi Co Starring Victoria Tate as Rena Robinson Shari Belafonte as Julia Johnson Hannah Leder Werntz as Isabella Joe Marinelli as Donny Eli Bildner as Joel Rapkin Amber Friendly as Layla Bell Joe Pacheco as Bart Michelle Meredith as Lindsey Augustus Prew as Sean Hiddleberg Katherine Ko as Dhillon Ian Gomez as Greg Markus Flanagan as Gerald Drummond David Magidoff as Nicky Kate Vernon as Geneva Mark Harelik as Richard Philip Anthony-Rodriguez as Gabriel Julian Morris as Andrew Cheyenne Jackson as Cheyenne Jackson Robert Cicchini as Robert T.J. Alvarado as Barista David Jahn as Desk Clerk Cory Tucker as Guy at Table Chris V. Pipkin as Waiter Michelle Kim as Hostess Noreen O'Neill as Barista Christopher Wallinger as Security Guard Russ Caro Zeller as Jane Andre Reiner Boyer as Host Christian Jacob as Pianist