Guest Stars Boris McGiver as Monsignor Matthew Korecki Sohina Sidhu as Karima Shakir Clark Johnson as Father Amara Danny Burstein as D.A. Lewis Cormier Noah Robbins as Sebastian Lewin John Glover as Byron Duke Laura Kai Chen as Marianne Jacobs Dascha Polanco as Patti Hitchens De'Adre Aziza as Fiona Plemmons Manoel Felciano as Jackson Orbinson Co Starring Amy Hohn as Judge Katrina Linden Aishling Pembroke as Young Woman (Possessed)