Guest Stars Jason Ritter as Eric Chandler Riggs as Patrick "PJ" Nelson Drea de Matteo as Barbara Nelson Melora Hardin as Patricia Bloom James Tupper as Andrew Pollock Ricky He as Don Jerry Ferrara as Todd Pilzner Co Starring Bodhi Sabongui as Elliot Debbie Podowski as Wendy Cruz Janet Glassford as Drama Teacher Meghan Drew as Emily Jason McKinnon as Ken Brannon Jannen Karr as Nancy Mat Lo as Maître D'