Guest Stars YaYa Gosselin as Natalia "Tali" Skye LaCroix J.C. MacKenzie as Judge Edward Philpot Marsha Stephanie Blake as Denise Tyson Christopher McLinden as Karl Buchman Joniece Abbott-Pratt as Michelle Carter Leopold Manswell as Damon Johnson Willie C. Carpenter as Glanville Tyson Co Starring Vitoria Setta as Rebecca Zayas Kelvin McGrue as S.A. Carr Nancy Nagrant as Principal Helen Wilkie Badia Farha as Mom Heather Girardi as Alex Bowers Benny Elledge as Johnnie Lee Vance Kelly Kirklyn as Carol Russo Inés Del Castillo as Maryland Trooper Alana Raquel Bowers as Jaynie / Karina John J. Concado as Carlos Quintana Da'Shawn Jackson as Kendall Tyson Dared Wright as Bill Russo David Chassen as Robbie's lawyer