Guest Stars Kerry Condon as Molly Sullivan Quincy Tyler Bernstine as Detective Perry Alan Alda as Dr. Arthur Amiot Peter Gerety as Jim Sullivan Josh Hamilton as Kevin Sullivan Kevin Corrigan as Declan Sullivan Delaney Williams as Judge Gregory Scholl Robert Funaro as Lt. Bricker Austin Hébert as Young Jim Sullivan Co Starring Tye Alexander as Arty Nathaniel Beal as Mark Emily Rose Richardson as Teen Bridget Donovan Nate Mann as Teen Ray Donovan Skyler Gallun as Teen Terry Donovan Rami Margron as Frankie Lee Ryan T. Connors as Older Teen Bunchy Faron Salisbury as Dean Connolly Paul Dederick as Cop