Guest Stars James Cusati-Moyer as Nico Stavros Michael Cerveris as Carter Berkhead Jeb Brown as County Sheriff Co Starring Esau Pritchett as Mr. David Kasjan Wilson as Young Malcolm Rowan O'Neil as Young Ainsley Ed Moran as Head Profiler Brette Taylor as Blair Berkhead Shaw Jones as FBI Supervisor #1 Caroline Vexler as Vanessa Hobbs Steve Beauchamp as Claude Springer Tom Greer as Cop #1 Kenya Brome as FBI Supervisor #2 Deborah Unger as Luisa Esteban Carmona as Cop #2 Matthew Greer as TV Reporter