Guest Stars Jordan Todosey as Tracey Creeker Shailyn Pierre-Dixon as Frances Jim Watson as Pat Creeker Krystal Nausbaum as Amanda Lotts Jesse Bostick as Felix Rosemary Dunsmore as Minister B. Miller Shailene Garnett as Amy Symonds Canute Gomes as Vincent Wesley Morgan as Kevin Hale Melanie Ng as TV Reporter Asyl Jet as Ben