Guest Stars Clark Middleton as Glen Carter Ken Leung as Assistant U.S. Attorney Michael Sima Becky Ann Baker as Judge Roberta Wilkins David Berman as Dr. Ogden Maguire Mark Linn-Baker as Dr. Jonathan Nikkila Matthew Porretta as Schmock Richard Toth as Bob Lockemy Co Starring Desi Waters as Court Clerk Kelley Curran as Co-Counsel Christianne Tisdale as Potential Juror #5 / Family of Crime Victim Liz McCartney as Potential Juror #4 / Pug Lady Lawrence Winslow as Potential Juror #6 / Veteran Guy Margo as Potential Juror #3 / Factory Worker Susan Oliveras as ER Nurse #2 Randy Kovitz as Committee Chairman Erika Woods as Officer Talbert Gerson Gomez as Tony Montez Tessa Frascogna as Girl Margaret Ivey as Staffer Elizabeth Inghram as Surgeon Cathy Salvodon as Potential Juror #2 / School Teacher Ralph Adriel Johnson as ER Nurse #1 Denia Brache as Rosa Nimo Gandhi as Abdul Kedir Jon Conver as Potential Juror #7 / Anarchist Nancy Meyer as Merriam Lockemy Lou Martini, Jr. as Potential Juror #1 / Cab Driver Clark Carmichael as Congressman #2