Special Guest Stars Alyson Michalka as Amy Samira Wiley as Detective Jessica Mathers Jessica St. Clair as Captain Ladee Tim Meadows as Adam Tim Matheson as Steve Joel McHale as Joel McHale Guest Stars Matt Corboy as Frank Madison McKinley as Maya Co Starring Noelle E Parker as Millie Evangeline Lindes as Crosby Sydney Brower as Everett Janzy Paraiso as Shoshana DeDe Drake as Julie Byron McIntyre as Doctor Chris McLaughlin as Witness Becki Dennis as Nurse Karen Kerry Rhodes as James