Guest Stars Sarah Gadon as Elisa Montgomery Mamie Gummer as Lucy Purcell Brett Cullen as Gerald Kindt Isaiah C. Morgan as Young Henry Hays Rhys Wakefield as Freddy Burns Michael Greyeyes as Brett Woodard Kennedi Lynn Butler as Young Becca Hays Tim Griffin as Special Agent Burt Diller Bea Santos as Adult Julie Purcell James MacDonald as Major Blevins Brian Oerly as Eddie Michael Broderick as Special Agent John Bowen Myk Watford as Detective Morelli L. Warren Young as 90's Detective #4 Bill Kelly as Detective Hobbs David Stanbra as Detective Segar Jodi Balfour as Lori Greg Bryan as Jay Bunda Bojesse Christopher as Detective Richard Kitting Brooklyn Courtney-Moore as Soda Can Girl #1 Mary Kathryn Bryant as State Police Receptionist John Earl Jelks as Sam Whitehead Lorenzo Yearby as Sam's Neighbor #1 Seth Barrish as Priest Sasha Morfaw as Sam's Neighbor #2 Joseph Curtis Callender as Liquor Store Proprietor Candyce Hinkle as Patty Faber David T. Anthony as TBD Chad Cline as Sallisaw PD Officer Berkeley Courtney-Moore as Soda Can Girl #2 Jon Walters as TBD