Guest Stars Melvin Gregg as DeMarcus Tillman Taylor Dearden as Chloe Lyman DeRon Horton as Lou Carter Jay Lee as Tanner Bassett Sarah Burns as Angela Montgomery Adam Ray as Officer Joe Crowder Bellina Logan as Det. Carla Dickey Barbara Deering as Cathy Wexler Cynthy Wu as Mia Abend Elisha Henig as Myles Crimmins Olivia Norman as Katherine Lake Miles J. Harvey as Paul Schnorrenberg Susan Ruttan as Patricia McClain Tim True as Coach Bob Devlin Jeanine Jackson as Proud Nun Jeremy Culhane as Grayson Wentz