Guest Stars Jaime Camil voices Don Karnage Kimberly Brooks voices Peg Leg Meg Keith Ferguson voices Ugly Mug David Tennant voices Hat Pirate Kimberly Brooks voices Hardtack Hattie Kimberly Brooks voices One-Eyed Linda Danny Pudi voices Pirate 1 Sam Riegel voices Stinky Boot Sam Riegel voices No-Name The Nameless Parrot Sam Riegel voices Two-Toed Jack Bobby Moynihan voices Pirate 2 Keith Ferguson voices Pirate Intern