Guest Stars Michael B. Silver as Sgt. Kanter Harris Danny Mastrogiorgio as Det. Anthony Fucci Alejandro Hernandez as Det. Rafael Sosa Peter Hermann as Russell Wright Charlie Semine as Steve Rizzo Lev Gorn as Uri Marshak Kate Arrington as Abby Wright Ito Aghayere as Tammy Sarkeysian Stephen Sable as David Wu Rodney Richardson as Tom "Tomahawk" Sarkeysian Co Starring John Mainieri as Det. Jimmy Marino Chuck Nice as Ryan Maceo Oliver as Security Officer Keke Lindgard as Guest Jenelle Chu as Lia Matt Wood as Justin Philip Hoffman as Professor John Herrera as Reverend Lilli Cooper as Marie Eston Fung as Restaurant Waiter Gareth Keegan as Billy Alma Cuervo as Marisol Neil Starkenberg as Waiter Leila Sbitani as Lara