Guest Stars Fiona Dourif as Lillian May Roth Michael Aronov as Joe "Smokey" Putnum Shane Patrick Kearns as Judson Caroline Lagerfelt as Vera Pruitt Taylor Vince as Lawrence Dean Devlin Alicia Minshew as Dr. Melissa Lomay Bob Gunton as Nicholas T. Moore Stephen McKinley Henderson as Dr. Francis Woerner Pamela Dunlap as Mrs. Moore Mikey Reid as W.P. Frost Austyn Johnson as Maybelle Co Starring Jeremy Gram Weaver as Kit Jorge Cordova as Dr. Brook Nina Kassa as Colleague Danielle Lee Greaves as Administrator Michael R. Pauley as SWAT Commander Jamie Soltis as Female Villager Isaac Beauchamp as Gunman Richert Easley as Male Elder Robb Sherman as Orderly Harley Yeager as Smoker Drew Reade as Spotter Caroline Hewitt as Pearl Celia Howard as Female Elder James T. Alfred as Officer Ronnie Glanton Manoel Felciano as Robert