Guest Stars Nasim Pedrad as Aly Nelson Curtis Armstrong as Alan Foster June Diane Raphael as Sadie Brian Posehn as Biology Teacher Zoe Lister-Jones as Fawn Moscato Co Starring Jonny Berryman as Dan Bill Bishop Isabella Marino as Older Ruth Nolan River as Reginald Veljohnson Joseph Krull as Moses Carmello Christian as Bishop Kid #1 Blake Anthony Crawford as Bishop Kid #2 Somali Rose as Bishop Kid #3 Amir Toussaint as Bishop Kid #4 Gabriella Celine as Bishop Kid #5