Guest Stars Shannon Purser as Annabelle Ellie Desautels as Michael Hallowell Sean Grandillo as Jeremy Tom Riis Farrell as Mr. Baer Rachel Hilson as Harmony Curtis Katherine Reis as Jolene Brooks Stephanie J. Block as Patricia Saunders Erin Kommor as Sasha Foley Jennifer Ferrin as Denise Strickland Brooklyn Shuck as Sadie Mazzuchelli Stanley Wayne Mathis as Principal Ward Stephen Plunkett as Robert Saunders Eisa Davis as Mrs. Thorne Mark Tallman as Detrell Thorne Margaret Rosiello as Emma Saunders Niloy Alam as Sundeep Singh Leslie Meisel as Nancy Ricardo Antonio Chavira as Johnny Cruz Shannon Thornton as Yvonne Thorne John Scurti as Superintendent Lewis Eric McKinley as Forrest