Guest Stars Kelly Rutherford as Paula Lannigan Christopher O'Shea as Noah Sager Jesse Rath as Special Agent Jeremy Riggs Chaske Spencer as Jimmy Diaz Seana Kofoed as Nancy Dillon Philippa Coulthard as Samantha Marcus LaVoi as Grant Holland Co Starring Garrett Kruithof as Anthony Silvera Molly Brown as Emily Rainbow Dickerson as Fiona Gardner Fiona Domenica as Nikki Vella Jen L. Burry as Chrissy Alpers