Guest Stars Alan Hale Jr. as Bartender at Broken Saddle Broderick Crawford as Kern Barnett Don Stroud as Arnold Alice Nunn as Barney Pat Buttram as Jonathan Evans/Toby Bridget Hanley as Shelby Barnett Stuart Whitman as Buck Yancy/Rough Rider John Russell as Second Oldtimer at Broken Saddle Jock Mahoney as First Oldtimer at Broken Saddle