Guest Stars Samantha Soule as Charlotte Temple Travis Hammer as John Doe Audrey Moore as Sarah Doyle Kayli Carter as Sadie Rose Matthew Dennis Lewis as Donnie Devlin Tess Frazer as Callie Dunne Adam David Thompson as Gatz Brown Rio Alexander as Bud Ledbetter Keith Jardine as Dyer Howe Joe Pingue as Alonzo Bunker Luke Robertson as Bill Chick Marie Wagenman as Trudy McNue Russell Dennis Lewis as Daryl Devlin Justin Welborn as Floyd Wilson Samuel Marty as Truckee Christiane Seidel as Martha Jeremy Bobb as A.T. Grigg Randy Oglesby as Asa Leopold Brian Lee Franklin as Amos Green Julian Grey as William McNue Sophia Silver as Saloon Sophia Russell G. Jones as Hiram Michael Earl Reid as Barney Mutz Duane Howard as Shoshone Brave Jessica Sula as Louise Hobbs John Lawlor as Elmer Knowland Eric LaRay Harvey as Elias Rob Morgan as John Randall Barbie Robertson as Julie Ann Elisa Perry as June Hobbs Courtney Cunningham as Mae Lela Rose Allen as School Girl Mathew Greer as Grandfather Damon Nathan Darrow as Webster Griffin Kane as 15 Year Old Roy Goode Rachel Singer as Betsy Emily Green as Biscuit Woman Chris Bylsma as Pastor Moore