Guest Stars Chris Mulkey as Colliar Sims Olivia Friedman as Kelly Sims Donzaleigh Abernathy as Sara Jackson Dan Byrd as Young Colliar Sims Nancy McLoughlin as Catherine O'Brien Elise Shirley as Young Teresa O'Brien Derrex Brady as Ajoni Williams Taneka Johnson as Lakeisha Reynolds Millie Perkins as Irene Otis