Special Guest Stars Alyson Michalka as Amy Samira Wiley as Detective Jessica Mathers Karen David as Priya Joel McHale as Himself Donald Faison as Himself Barry Shabaka Henley as Captain Jackson Guest Stars Steven Krueger as Orson Thomas Barbusca as Jonathan Sneakz Arielle Vandenberg as Jillian Co Starring Noelle E Parker as Millie Evangeline Lindes as Crosby Sydney Brower as Everett Matt Corboy as Frank Brad Pennington as Catering Boss Chris Grace as Michael Cjon Saulsberry as Security Guard