Guest Stars Katie Finneran as Belle Rayburn Chloë Sevigny as Chelsea O'Bannon Steven Pasquale as Alec Wolos Frank Hoyt Taylor as Lenny Potts Mia Kirshner as Sarah Rayburn Co Starring Zachary T. Robbins as Young John Rayburn Eliezer Castro as Carlos Mejia Randy Gonzalez as Manny The Bellman Chris Marazzo as Young Lenny Potts Cindy Karr as Susan Widmark Julie Upton as Karen Rourke Brigitte Kali Canales as Cristina Colon Jeff Chase as Burly Guy Adam Brudnicki as Boyfriend Fedor Steer as Babyfaced Man Aimee Bowen as Wealthy Woman Krystal Lynn Hedrick as Sexy Girl Andrea Preisler Crouch as Tricia