Guest Stars Conrad Ricamora as Oliver Hampton Tom Verica as Sam Keating Megan West as Lila Stangard Arjun Gupta as Kan Alysia Reiner as D.A. Wendy Parks Marcia Gay Harden as Hannah Keating April Parker-Jones as Detective Claire Bryce Tamlyn Tomita as Judge Carol Morrow Aaron Benjamin Miller as Nerdy Intellectual Mallory Low as Eager Girl Faran Tahir as Detective Terrence Amos Crystal Coney as Reporter #1 Jason Sims-Prewitt as Police Officer #1 Alex Marshall-Brown as Seamstress Mandy Levin as Woman #2 Carrie Armstrong as Receptionist Francesca Ferrara as Woman #1 J. Trevor Davis as Mr. Ingram Louisa Hodge as Reporter #2 Ethan Corn as Male Student