Guest Stars Danielle Burgess as Madeline "Maddie" Beecham Enid Graham as Elizabeth Lacey C.J. Wilson as William Lacey Susan Pourfar as Ms. Hutchins Jacob Pitts as JD Lambert Kathryn Erbe as Faye Ambrose Peggy Gormley as Judge Diana Baird Nadia Alexander as Adult Phoebe Joseph Melendez as District Attorney Lopez Joanna P. Adler as Captain Ann Farmer