Special Guest Stars Victor Garber as Neil Nutterman Guest Stars Ruby Jerins as Grace Peyton Dominic Fumusa as Kevin Peyton Daisy Tahan as Fiona Peyton Anna Deavere Smith as Dr. Akalitis Elizabeth Marvel as Ginny Flynn Co Starring Stephen Wallem as Thor Cassady Leonard as Kaitlyn Flynn Jill Flint as Melissa Greenfield Christopher Abbott as Andy Singer Eddie Korbich as Tap Instructor Ptolemy Slocum as Jeweler Garrett Hendricks as Technician #1