Guest Stars Timothy Omundson as Sean Potter Kristin Lehman as Dr. Lily Reddicker Sarah Danielle Madison as Dr. Heather Labonte Dave Rudy as Dr. Lloyd Kathryne Dora Brown as Zola Knox June Squibb as Louise Flowers Nancy Stafford as Judge Bell Brian McNamara as D.A. Baseer John Aylward as Father Jack Monroe Erin Sanders as Janice Witherspoon Chad Todhunter as Henry Genovese Edith Fields as Mrs. Sanko Tina Holmes as Tina Siegel Joe Wandell as Paramedic Evan Sabara as Avery Siegel Lou Saliba as Defense Attorney John Ganun as Glenn Orth Ronn Surels as Guy in Bar Destiny Edmond as Melissa Blanton Molly Cheek as Cecile - Course Instructor Callie Waterman as Jennifer Hans