Guest Stars Mitch Longley as Jonathan Ashworth Lucinda Jenney as Allison Cossey Penny Fuller as Mrs. Madsen Rebecca Lowman as Erma Basting Will Rothhaar as Anthony Cossey Jarrett Lennon as Theodore Plunket Kara Houston as Lynn Dickinson Carlie Westerman as Claire Cossey Alan Loayza as Finn Christopher Wynne as Sgt. Heffner Cynthia Graham as Female Officer Jeff Van Atta as Carl Monroe