Guest Stars Jillian Armenante as Donna Kozlowski Wendy Makkena as Susie Nixon Jeana LaVardera as Lisa Matthews Angela Sarafyan as Aisha Al-Jamal Claudette Nevins as Karen Cassidy Drew Snyder as Bill Cassidy Joel Swetow as Marvin Gellman Robert Walden as Ian Tyson Rusty Schwimmer as Alice Benedict Jeff Harlan as Rick Buchanan Scott Alan Smith as Colin Wright John Vickery as Dwayne Cochrane Michael Murphy as Judge Alistair McNeil Biff McGuire as Judge Helmstadler Bennet Guillory as Arthur Ethelridge Clarinda Ross as Andi Herick Dori Mizrahi as Wahid-Al-Jamal