Guest Stars Carrie Preston as Sister Katrina Aidan Devine as Father Joe Scofield Co Starring Jeffrey R. Smith voices Muse Ted Dykstra voices Muse Scotch Ellis Loring voices Muse Bryan Hatt as Night Cleaner Boyd Banks as Janitor Sean Sullivan as Ticket Guy Stefanie Samuels as Female Police Officer Richard Quesnel as Young Police Officer Karen Ivany as Marta Isabella Lobo as Scofield's Little Girl Michael Cronin as Police Officer #1