Guest Stars Nicki Aycox as Meg Masters Jeffrey Dean Morgan as John Winchester William B. Davis as Professor Tom Butler as Harley Jorgeson Tania Saulnier as Emily Jorgeson P. Lynn Johnson as Stacey Jorgeson Co Starring David Orth as Sheriff Brendan Penny as Steve Brent Stait as Scotty Lara Gilchrist as Holly Parker Angela Moore as Bus Station Clerk Dean Wray as Driver #1 Leah Graham as Pauly Mike Carpenter as The Scarecrow Christian Schrapff as Vince Parker Tim O'Halloran as Driver #2