The Secret Circle Guest cast, played by Grey Damon Episode 1x10: Darkness (Jan 5, 2012) Episode 1x11: Fire/Ice (Jan 12, 2012) Episode 1x12: Witness (Jan 19, 2012) Episode 1x14: Valentine (Feb 9, 2012) Episode 1x15: Return (Feb 16, 2012) Episode 1x16: Lucky (Mar 15, 2012)